World

Deutsche Bank shaken: Dangerous games with "hidden" 800 million losses in Italy, Project Aetos up in the air

Deutsche Bank shaken: Dangerous games with
Shadowy accounting at Germany's largest bank

Serious questions regarding risk management practices, internal controls, and corporate governance at Deutsche Bank are raised by revelations from the Financial Times, according to which the Italian subsidiary of the German banking group allegedly concealed mortgage losses reaching up to 800 million euros through a complex system of derivatives and parallel accounting practices. The case, which reportedly remained active for more than a decade, reveals a web of problematic practices, supervisory deficiencies, and handling that, according to the bank's internal investigation, affected the profitability picture of the Italian unit.Deutsche Bank, for its part, denies that there was any need to revise previous financial statements, arguing that the transactions had been accurately reflected in the group's consolidated financial statements and that no further disclosure at the group level was required.

The "tesoretto" and the alleged concealment of mortgage losses

At the center of the case lies a mechanism allegedly created by executives of Deutsche Bank's Italian unit, known as "tesoretto," meaning a small hidden reserve. According to the Financial Times, this specific reserve was used to cover deviations from profitability targets, through accounting adjustments that did not reflect the true financial picture of operations. The practice allegedly enabled the Italian unit to report stronger performance, despite the losses and problems that had accumulated in its mortgage loan portfolio.Profitability targets were reportedly met by utilizing this specific reserve across different time periods, including in 2011, 2014, and 2016. The internal investigation reportedly concluded that the results of both the Italian unit and the group had undergone arbitrary accounting adjustments, which distorted the true picture of performance.

900 million euros in derivatives without clear economic justification

The case takes on a particular dimension due to the use of financial derivatives, as according to the findings of the internal investigation, the Italian unit allegedly established derivative positions totaling approximately 900 million euros without clear economic justification. These specific positions were reportedly linked to an effort to hedge risks from mortgage loans, yet the handling and assumptions used did not adequately correspond to actual market data and customer behavior. The problem is tied to changes in Italian legislation starting in 2007, which allowed borrowers of fixed-rate mortgage loans to proceed with early repayment without additional penalties.Deutsche Bank allegedly failed to adapt in time to these changes, maintaining pricing and risk management models that did not adequately reflect the possibility of early loan settlement. Falling interest rates during the Eurozone debt crisis amplified the phenomenon, as more customers proceeded with refinancing or early repayment of higher-rate mortgage loans. As a result, the bank allegedly held hedging positions that were no longer necessary, generating additional losses and weighing on its financial position.

The Project Aetos investigation and the 779 million euro losses

The case began to come to light in 2018, when internal complaints and executive concerns led to the launch of an investigation codenamed "Project Aetos." The investigation reportedly uncovered serious weaknesses in mortgage loan management, internal control systems, risk monitoring, and financial reporting procedures. According to figures cited by the Financial Times, Deutsche Bank recognized a financial charge of approximately 522 million euros in 2020, while if unrealized losses are included, the total potential cost was estimated at 779 million euros. The case was not limited, however, solely to accounting discrepancies. The internal investigation reportedly found that the Italian unit failed for an extended period to transmit critical data on mortgage loans to the group's central risk management systems. According to the findings, approximately 2.8 billion euros in loans and 1.4 billion euros in early repayments had not been recorded in the central systems as required, resulting in significant gaps in capturing credit and financial risk. Concurrently, the Italian unit had reportedly been burdened with internal funding costs of approximately 235 million euros, which were ultimately written off by the group.

Audits, KPMG, and questions over supervision

The case also raises serious questions regarding Deutsche Bank's internal and external audit mechanisms.KPMG, which had undertaken the audit of the Italian unit during the period when the disputed practices allegedly unfolded, did not detect this specific reserve system, according to the Financial Times report. Following the internal investigation, it also reportedly maintained that a revision of the financial statements was not necessary. The matter carries particular weight, as the case had reportedly raised concerns as early as 2013, while certain weaknesses in risk management had been identified in 2014 without the necessary corrective actions being implemented in time. The revelations highlight a broader problem: how practices related to mortgage pricing, risk hedging, and loss recognition could persist for years without control mechanisms being effectively triggered.

No executives fired - Millions in severance and bonuses in the spotlight

Even more striking is the dimension concerning how accountability was handled after the case came to light. According to the Financial Times, Deutsche Bank did not proceed with firing executives linked to the case, as the internal investigation found no evidence of deliberate misconduct or coordinated fraud. However, the same investigation reportedly cited negligence or incompetence, while identifying significant weaknesses in the exercise of management duties. Several executives departed from the bank in 2020, as part of changes to the management structure of the Italian unit, while additional departures took place in 2021.Severance packages reportedly totaled approximately 8.1 million euros for some of the departing executives, while the bank decided not to claw back deferred compensation amounting to 5.25 million euros. This development raises reasonable questions as to whether accountability mechanisms at a major international banking group function effectively when serious failures are identified at the level of management and risk control.

Deutsche Bank responds - No need to restate balance sheets

Deutsche Bank sought to contain the fallout from the revelations, arguing that the findings concerning the Italian subsidiary were reviewed with the external auditor and that a restatement of financial statements for prior periods was not deemed necessary. The bank maintained that the transactions had been properly reflected in the group's financial statements and that no additional disclosure was required, as the matter did not have a material impact on the performance of the group or individual business divisions. At the same time, it stated that it conducted a review of funding assumptions, due to changes in local legislation that affected customer behavior, as well as corrective actions and accountability measures.Deutsche Bank's position stands, however, in contrast to the Financial Times revelations, which describe a system allegedly maintained over a series of years that affected the presentation of the Italian unit's financial performance.

New blow to Deutsche Bank's reputation

The case comes at a time when Deutsche Bank is once again under pressure over past practices and corporate governance issues. The revelations form part of a broader journalistic investigation titled "Inside Deutsche Bank," which is based on a leak of millions of internal documents and examines controversial activities of the banking group.Deutsche Bank's track record includes major judicial, supervisory, and regulatory cases, with the cost of litigation and settlements having weighed heavily on the bank in previous years. The new case involving the Italian subsidiary brings back to the forefront the debate over whether major European banks possess adequate mechanisms to control their subsidiaries, as well as whether transparency in financial statements reflects actual economic conditions. The core question now concerns not only the size of the losses, but how a system of questionable accounting practices allegedly persisted for such a long period, who knew of its weaknesses, and why corrective interventions were not carried out earlier.

www.bankingnews.gr

Latest Stories

Readers’ Comments

Also Read